|
Post by kullenuska on Jul 4, 2014 19:45:01 GMT -8
(Let's see how well this goes! If anyone is against this or think it needs changing, let me know, but otherwise general consensus says people want MORE FEEDBACK)
This is a thread for those in Iron Splicer who want a bit more detailed feedback on their entries! The judge panel can't fit a novel of advice into every sprite that comes through, obviously. But sometimes what they say is very vague as a result. Want a little bit of help with that? The judges - and others, if you feel like you want to contribute something helpful - are willing to lend a hand! They can't break their anonymity for the comments on the feedback, (so don't ask them to fess up to anything they've said about the entries) but multiple judges can notice the same problem on a sprite - so don't go guessing ;3
General rules: -Of course, you can't get help on pieces that haven't been judged yet, because that would be unfair. -Be nice! You can be harsh, but be as constructive as possible. Don't be outright insulting - say what you don't like, why you don't like it, and what can be done to make it better! -Iron Splicer entries only. There's more critique threads for general splices out there if you want.
-I'm not sure if it should be open critique or not, but I know that a lot of issues are repetitive with the judges so they'd know more what they're looking for and how to fix it. For now, feedback from judges only, but this is subject to change. Let me know.
If you have any resources you'd like to share, include those too! There's always something in the rest of the help threads.
|
|
|
Post by pokemonscrap on Jul 5, 2014 8:26:17 GMT -8
I like this idea, and I'm definitely interested to see how it works out! (Plus, I'm glad I don't have to be the one to moderate it.)
|
|